About Us | Game Reviews | Feature Articles | Podcast | Best Work | Forums | Shop | Review Game

Heavy Rain Second Opinion

Trent Fingland's picture

The Game of Life

Heavy Rain Screenshot

HIGH Surviving the climactic battle with Mad Jack.

LOW Glitches can absolutely kill the impact of some scenes.

WTF Clown: "Sir, you haven't paid me yet!" Ethan: "Keep the Change." Clown: "Sir, you haven't paid me yet!" Ethan: "Keep the change." Clown: "Sir, you haven't paid me yet!" Repeat 10 times.

Back when survival-horror games were a capital-T "Thing," the gaming community was blown away by the discovery that video games—kids' toys, really—could inspire genuine emotion. In that case: fear. The decline of the genre was accompanied by the rise of a question: What other emotions can games inspire? Apart from the low-profile efforts of Fumito Ueda (ICO, Shadow of the Colossus), woefully few have approached this issue directly. Cue Heavy Rain, which elevates the question of emotions in games to mainstream status, skillfully handling the topic itself in the process. (Reader beware: To better discuss the game, I've included some spoilers in the review.)

In the game's opening moments I assumed control of Ethan Mars, waking to a beautiful new day in his incredibly stylish house. Aside from Ethan's own thoughts suggesting that he get some work done while the family was out—he's a work-from-home architect—I was given free reign over how to spend my (his? our?) time. After a bit of probing around, I was shocked to find that there were actual cartoons on TV. Not a few still images in rotation, a typical way of handling TV in games, but a fully animated (though brief) show with a plot and characters. I was fascinated by this cartoon, surprised by the amount of effort put into something so peripheral, but my trance was abruptly broken when the wife and kids came home. What's that? How much work had I gotten done this morning? Er... I spent all day watching cartoons.

It was at that instant that I drank the Kool-Aid. Experiencing that flash of "oh shi—", while an embarrassingly familiar sensation in my daily life, felt completely alien (and completely refreshing) when the source was a video game. Heavy Rain is filled with sequences that trigger the mundane but complex emotional responses that are mostly reserved for the rigors of real life. The stakes are often much grander than typical day-to-day affairs—at one point Ethan must choose between cutting off his own finger or missing out on a clue to his missing son's whereabouts—but the decision making process closely emulated real life. Instead of basing my choice on which option yielded the best rewards or most experience, I found myself relying on totally foreign (to games, anyway) criteria. Do I really have to do this? Can I piece together the clues I already have? Will there be repercussions if I don't do it?

Heavy Rain Screenshot

There is usually no correct answer. Often there isn't even a narrative consequence, which may sound unfulfilling, or even lazy from a development perspective, but this yet another aspect in which Heavy Rain reflects real life. In reality, we are often confronted with choices where the only consequence of choosing is a newly-adjusted perspective.

The aforementioned finger-removal scene is a great example of this. After choosing to do the deed, Ethan must find appropriate tools for the job. Weighing my options, I decided to go with the wire cutters (ouch!) and made sure to have some disinfectant ready post-dismemberment. Ethan cuts off his pinky in one (relatively) clean motion, then douses the wound with disinfectant. When my girlfriend played the same scene she grabbed the nearest implement, a rusty saw, and made no other preparations. Ethan proceeded to painfully butcher himself, and then stumble out of the room with a fresh, bleeding stump where a finger used to be.

The results were the same in both instances; Ethan received a new hint, and pressed onward in his quest. What changed was the context. In one scene, Ethan was resigned to his gory task, but was collected enough to think of his own well-being. In the other, Ethan was a desperate, self-destructive father willing to do anything to find his son. The genius of these seemingly pointless decisions is that they allow different gamers to view the same character as a totally different person. Though the narrative arc might be similar across groups, the four heroes end up with unique personas depending on whoever is holding the controller.

After finishing the game, I was interested in seeing how scenarios might develop when played differently. On attempting a few critical chapters, I found that I couldn't motivate myself to continue. All of the new paths and interactions felt hollow and illegitimate after having experienced the ups and downs of my original playthrough. While this is seen as a weakness by many, I counted it as one of the game's greatest virtues. I had a real sense of ownership of that original experience. More than just the curious experimentation of a gamer, the events that transpired over the course of the story felt like they belonged to me. It might sound pretentious, but the replay value was undermined by the fact that additional attempts violated the sanctity of my initial experience.

This isn't to say that Richard's appraisal of the game was wrong. On the contrary, it was entirely correct. The controls are awkward, technical glitches abound, and the storyline jumps the shark in magnificent fashion. Even so, Heavy Rain's most grievous missteps are inconsequential in the face of its achievements. Playing around with the kids in the backyard instead of helping my wife set the table for dinner is one of the most memorable experiences I've ever had in my gaming career, and no amount of audio skipping or plot holes can diminish that memory. Rating: 9.0 out of 10.

Disclosures: This game was obtained via retail store and reviewed on the PS3. Approximately 6 hours of play were devoted to single-player modes (completed 1 time).

Category Tags
Platform(s): PS3  
Developer(s): Quantic Dream  
Key Creator(s): David Cage  
Publisher: Sony  
Series: Heavy Rain  
Genre(s): Adventure/Explore  
ESRB Rating: Mature (17+)  
Articles: Game Reviews  

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

This is the review (and

This is the review (and score) I had expected to see first time round. But i guess thats one of the most beautiful things about Heavy Rain (as you said in the review) is that everyone takes a different perspective of not only the individual trials, the characters, the plot, but it can also lead to such vastly differing opinions of the overall experience.

Personally, its one of the best games i've played in the past couple of years and I wouldn't rate it higher than 8.5. I have played games in that time that I think are lesser games, but would give them a higher score.

Like it or hate it, it is a game that is not so much played, but experienced.

I was hoping someone would

I was hoping someone would write this. The dividing point between me and the rest of the gaming population doesn't seem to be whether any of the criticisms I flung at it were valid, but whether or not the composition of some of the individual scenes made up for that. I really wish they did, since I very much wanted to like Heavy Rain, but all of its problems just became too much for me to look past.

Whatever floats your boat I guess :)

Well said

I like how you seem content with the limited but significant wiggle room allowed to the player, whereas so many other critics were frustrated with the lack of real consequence and the restraints imposed on story advancement (an 8-hour quicktime event, blah blah blah). I can't say the distinctness of my first playthrough prevented me from going at it a second time (far from it), but I can understand how it felt close to you and, having experienced it from other games, definitely see it as a virtue. Heavy Rain is a game that begs to be FELT in the way you describe, in the nuances of how you choose to conduct a scene ; I have read too few accounts that defended this aspect so well.

Just finished Heavy Rain last night...

... and wanted to check out what the GC crew thought.

Trent, I completely and utterly fall in line with your review. In the opening sequence, puttered around the house, played with one of the kid's remote control cars, and then sketched a building. Once the family got home, I chose to help my wife set the table with her grandmother's dishes and sweated every second thinking I was going to break one.

Then I went outside to play with the kids. During the play swordfight with Jason, my gamer instinct initially led me to start winning the fight. After a few times hitting Jason, I thought "You know, this is a kid, I should let him win." Then I intentionally started missing buttons. Jason slashed me in the leg, then he stabbed me in the stomach, and my character collapsed to the ground in a fake death. And when Jason cheered in victory, that's when I drank the Kool-Aid. The scene's inversion of the tradition QTE objective was an incredibly personal experience for me.

I'm a new father here, so perhaps my perspective made it more likely to get into the narrative emotionally than for some others. To me, the scene-by-scene composition and small level decision-making was simply amazing and I really hope this developer and others continue along these lines, and continue improvements in narratives and controls.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Code of Conduct

Comments are subject to approval/deletion based on the following criteria:
1) Treat all users with respect.
2) Post with an open-mind.
3) Do not insult and/or harass users.
4) Do not incite flame wars.
5) Do not troll and/or feed the trolls.
6) No excessive whining and/or complaining.

Please report any offensive posts here.

For more video game discussion with the our online community, become a member of our forum.

Our Game Review Philosophy and Ratings Explanations.

About Us | Privacy Policy | Review Game | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook |  RSS
Copyright 1999–2010 GameCritics.com. All rights reserved.