About Us | Game Reviews | Feature Articles | Podcast | Best Work | Forums | Shop | Review Game

Consoleation: My Top Five Consoles of All Time

Peter Skerritt's picture

With this console generation coming to a close, and with the strong likelihood that this will mark the end of buying modern consoles for me, I thought I'd look back and rank my top five consoles of all time. These are my rankings, my criteria, and my words. Your mileage can and will certainly vary.

The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask Screenshot

5. Nintendo 64

I recently wrote an entire piece about the Nintendo 64 and why it's the console that I'm hoping to add to my collection next. Interestingly enough, many of my favorite N64 games were third-party offerings, which is something that I really haven't been able to say about a Nintendo platform since then. Aside from RPGs, which the PlayStation really dominates, the N64 has a decent variety of games to choose from. Great platformers, solid coin-op conversions, a few quality first-person games, a couple of really good Star Wars games, and more. I have more than a few fond memories of the platform, even though I took it for granted when I had it during the late 1990s.

Crazy Taxi Screenshot

4. Dreamcast

It was a short but eventful and highly enjoyable run for Sega's final hardware platform. My favorite memories of the Dreamcast are of the arcade-perfect coin-op conversions that we saw for it. Midway ported NFL Blitz 2000, Hydro Thunder, and NBA Showtime and it was like having the arcade machines in my apartment. Crazy Taxi and Virtua Tennis were fantastic, too. I can't forget about SoulCalibur, either; that game still holds up more than 13 years later. Dreamcast original games like Shenmue, Seaman, Metropolis Street Racer, Skies of Arcadia, and others expanded the experience beyond arcade roots and blew my doors off. The 2K sports games were also noteworthy. It's a shame that the Dreamcast couldn't hang in there a bit longer, but I'll always look back on it fondly.

Final Fantasy II Screenshot

3. Super Nintendo Entertainment System

It was tough to decide between the second and third spots, but the Super Nintendo gets the third spot. The SNES represents a lot of personal firsts: the first console I ever bought on my own, the first RPG I ever played (Final Fantasy II), the first Castlevania game I ever played, and the first time I (irresponsibly) chose buying a game over paying bills (Street Fighter II). The games were (and still are) are generally good to great, the controller was arguably the basis of controllers that would come later, the sound was amazing for the time, and Mode 7 graphics showed us things that we'd never seen before with scaling and rotation. A surprising number of SNES games still hold up well nearly 20 years later, too. The Genesis might have done a few things better in terms of CPU speed and fewer instances of slowdown, but to me, the SNES was the winner of the 16-bit war.

Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty Screenshot

2. PlayStation 2

After being impressed by Sony's first console, I was prepared to be impressed by the PlayStation 2. The Dreamcast held my interest at first, though… and it wasn't until the Dreamcast's demise that I finally jumped on board the PlayStation 2 train. From that point on, in February of 2001, I was hooked and haven't looked back since. It wasn't the most powerful of the platforms during its generation, but the variety of games available for the PS2 was unmatched. Arcade ports, quirky titles, RPGs, music/rhythm games, sports games, racing games, action games, compilation discs, and many more genres all found homes on the PS2. It was still the exclusive home for Final Fantasy, Metal Gear Solid, Tekken, Ace Combat, and other major IPs while also playing games like Mister Mosquito, Mad Maestro, Katamari Damacy, and several more. Backwards compatibility also means that the also-great library of games for the original PlayStation is largely playable and adds to the huge number of games available. The PlayStation 2 will be awesome for many years to come.

Super Mario Bros. Screenshot

1. Nintendo Entertainment System

To me, the Nintendo Entertainment System really marked the beginning of several things. It was the beginning of the merge into mainstream culture that video games had never seen before. It was the the beginning for series like The Legend of Zelda, Metroid, Mega Man, Castlevania, Final Fantasy, Dragon Quest, and others. It was also the beginning of my genuine fascination with consoles and a gradual move away from arcades to arcade-at-home experiences. The NES controller is a picture of simplicity with its two face buttons and directional pad. Many NES games are highly accessible, although the difficulty curve on some of them can be daunting. Some of my first attempts at writing video game reviews were based on NES games, so the platform has personal significance in that regard, too. Perhaps the most important thing is that I find the games to still be highly enjoyable, even some 25 or more years later. NES games may not be the prettiest-looking games, the passwords may be miles long at times, there may be an inordinate number of princesses that need saving, and the games may not be complex by today's standards… but I can honestly say that the NES is the one system that I'd take if I was left on a deserted island or if I had to choose one platform to play solely for the rest of my days. To me, that alone earns the NES its #1 spot.

So, there you have them: my top five consoles of all time. For what it's worth, the Genesis is in the sixth spot, just outside of the rankings and based solely on its sports games. I didn't include handhelds on this list.

I open the floor to you, if you'd like. What are your top consoles of all time? List as many or as few as you'd like in the comments below. Feel free to cite reasons, too– it makes list entries more fun and I'm certainly interested in your reasoning. Have fun with it… and thanks a lot for reading my own list.

Category Tags
Platform(s): Nintendo DS   PS2   Dreamcast   Nintendo 64   Game Boy Advance  
Articles: Editorials   Columns  
Topic(s): Pop-culture  

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Thinkng back on it all....

Your article was a nice trip down memory lane, although I confess to being more interested as to why this current generation of consoles may be your last (which is your private business, so I expect no response).

In my family as a youth, money could be tight, so my first console was bought by myself when I got out of college, and that was a SNES. Since then I've bought nearly console that came out up to this generation. I thought myself never to be painfully loyal to any particular brand of console; I preferred the cherry-picking approach (e.g., buy both the PS1 and N64, and buy the best, most unique game exclusive to each (although in this day and age of coss-platform games, this approach is not very practical).

My love of consoles was very strong, and only seemed to fade as more adult responsibilities came along (well...not so much as fade, as much as less free time..), and my kids, who once would watch in awe of my video game prowess, now complete a game 2/3 quicker than I can (when I have the time to play games).

Up through the PS2/XBOX era, gaming was exclusively a solo experience for me, and not until this generation did online console gaming (in my opinion only) really come into play.

This is where my love for console has significantly dropped; don't get me wrong, I still love the games, and even occassionally get to do some online, but I have definitely lost the "gotta have it now" mantra when it comes to games and consoles...and also because my kids have gotten dependent on Daddy to get the latest games, even if it takes me weeks/months before I have the chance to sit down and play for more than 30 minutes (which is why mobile gaming has come on so strong for me).

But I digress.....and here are my top five consoles:
5 - SNES: It was my introduction to video games, and i got to meet Zelda for the 1st time.

4 - Sega CD: Go ahead and laugh! While there were very few good games (Snatcher, anyone?!), this is the console that made me look at the technology being used, and guided me towards the path of engineering.

3 - PS1: Metal Gear, Warhawk, Parasite Eve, Resident Evil. Vast new horizons with the graphical capabilities I envisioned since the SNES days. Was I Red E? You betcha!

2- XBOX: The brash young upstart to Sony and Nintendo. I really like the exclusive, lesser known games this console would get (Panzer Dragoon Orta, Gun Valkyrie).

1- XBOX360: 4 main reasons why: (1) Filling up a 60GB hard drive with Game Installs got real old, real quick, (2) You could easily upgrade the original XBOX360 console to WLAN capability, whereas I could not with the PS3 original model, (3) Superior (in my opinion) controller design, and (4)How quickly I could play a game once inserting the disk (see (1) above).

If nothing else, when your #1 console becomes moreso about ease of use, as compared to the fun times in playing the game, maybe it is time to stop playing.

Don't ignore the 'non-consoles'

I know you're probably giving up consoles and going retro, but let me get one thing very clear:'Retro gaming' does NOT only mean (S)NES/Sega System gaming.

Consoles have only been the dominant entertainment form factor on my shores since the PS1. Before that, the strongest heritage of gaming can be traced back through the 8-16-32 bit eras from Spectrum/C64 to Amiga/AtariST and finally to 'PC'. (Of course, the latter always existed, but only became a viable gaming platform in the early 90s when the necessary graphics (VGA) and audio (Soundblaster) technologies converged.)

No retro reviewer worth his salt can ignore these systems as they are where the overwhelming majority of today's industry leaders honed their skills, where many of today's development / publishing houses were formed, and where today's genres were born and refined.

The problem with Nintendo was, and still is, that they are/were a closed shop - a single publishing house, with strict quality controls enforcing a top-down culture of innovation rather than being a bottom-up breeding ground - hence limited to a very small selection of albeit, high quality, titles.

Compare and contrast to the diversity of classics on the 'non-consoles' that are far too many to mention. Jet Set Willy, Chuckie Egg, Knight Lore, Spy Hunter, Elite moving onto the likes of Bards Tale, Speedball 2, Pinball Dreams, Populous, Beneath a Steel Sky and then on the early PC, X-Wing, System Shock, Civilisation, SimCity, Monkey Island etc etc

The point I'm trying to make is that, non-console based gaming was probably more influential on the gaming industry than consoles ever were prior to the PS1. The sheer volume and diversity of games on systems outside of the consoles back then speaks for itself, and if you're going to go retro, you absolutely need to have an appreciation of this.

Retro gaming is more, much much more, than just Zelda, Mario and Megaman!

I'd put the PSX over the PS2

I'd put the PSX over the PS2 but that's just my opinion.

Console gaming has been trending to be like pop or country music for awhile now. Its mostly superfluous shallow half assery than. Taking a product and reducing tis quality to sell to more people is never a good thing and frankly the game price point is laughable if its over 20 its likely to not be worth wasting time on.

Also it costs roughly a grand to a grand and a half every five'ish years to have a solid enough foundation to chose the best games on. Its just not worth fooling with half the time for the price.They need to aim their hardware specs lower and build games that cost 30$ of which the Oyua and valves set top box might just destroy he current console war landscape.

I agree! I was rockin' the

I agree!

I was rockin' the C-64 and Amiga 500 up until 1989, when I finally bought the NES. A year and a half later I moved on from the NES to the Genesis.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Code of Conduct

Comments are subject to approval/deletion based on the following criteria:
1) Treat all users with respect.
2) Post with an open-mind.
3) Do not insult and/or harass users.
4) Do not incite flame wars.
5) Do not troll and/or feed the trolls.
6) No excessive whining and/or complaining.

Please report any offensive posts here.

For more video game discussion with the our online community, become a member of our forum.

Our Game Review Philosophy and Ratings Explanations.

About Us | Privacy Policy | Review Game | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook |  RSS
Copyright 1999–2010 GameCritics.com. All rights reserved.