Above and Beyond the Call of at least One Duty

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Screenshot

HIGH Covering a human player with AC-130 armory.

LOW A hole-ridden plot that ends in obvious sequel bait.

WTF Tactical nuke?!

Infinity Ward has its greatest argument for moving away from history's most documented battles in Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 . From gothic Russian gulags to a D.C. battlefield that feels like a precursor to Fallout 3's Capital Wasteland, the setpieces are no longer silicon documentaries, but rather extended tours into the developers' frenzied gun-fetish daydreams of national landmarks being destroyed. 

The game is of two minds. One offers a faux-high-minded military fantasy. The other, of course, is to provide the perfect multiplayer shooting experience—an honor argued for heralded titles like GoldenEye, Halo, and Counterstrike. The latter succeeds wildly. The former less so, but Modern Warfare 2 swaggers in with nuclear aplomb either way. 

When it comes to multiplayer competition and cooperative gameplay, who am I to deny this game's greatness? The controls are almost ergonomic, fitting like a well-worn glove. The multiplayer maps, from war-torn Afghanistan to a terror-ridden airport, are huge, balanced and believable. Online, the player can level up to gain new skills and weapons to customize your character. The plus-figure you see with every confirmed kill feed a narcissistic desire for superiority only the best role-playing games can provide. 

Nobody expected any less. The biggest surprise from the first Modern Warfare is the sublime Spec Ops mode. It has been initially compared to Horde Mode in Gears of War 2, a comparison that is both incorrect and unflattering. 

Spec Ops mode is the single-player game stripped down to its most elemental, except it can be shared with a friend. They are objective-based missions without the fuss of a story or character motivation, and despite the surge of cooperative play in games, Infinity Ward was still able to innovate. If you're like me and have wished of playing the gunner of a God-like AC-130 warship protecting a teammate through a nightmarish warzone, then our fever dream has been fulfilled. It's an offering you can't find anywhere else. Then there are snowmobile races, helicopter escort missions, and house-to-house, diner-to-diner fighting in Americana. The missions are challenging, hectic and the sense of virtual reward after completing a mission on the hardest difficulty setting is immense.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Screenshot

Modern Warfare 2 achieves glory in online competition and cooperative play when it sheds the pretension of its single-player campaign, which tells the tale of an all-out war between the U.S. and Russia, and the shadow group of international operatives who try to cool the instability. 

First I'd like to point out an easy but unfair criticism of the Call of Duty stories; that its writing is reminiscent of the critically-maligned blockbuster filmmaker Jerry Bruckheimer. It's better than that at least. It's all very loud and macho, but there's a very natural sense of pacing. Infinity Ward shows great affection for some of its characters, particularly "Soap" Mactavish, the protagonist from the first Modern Warfare who returns as this game's nigh-certifiable superhero, although not its main playable character. The plot and character development thankfully avoid any jingoism. The game's morality is muddied somewhat, making it more intriguing than your standard Nazi caper. 

Composer Hans Zimmer (The Dark Knight) has a score that swells as the player approaches a burning White House. It's a lot of sound and fury, and it's hard not to get goosebumps. Infinity Ward has an acute sense for player behavior, triggering events and musical cues as the player guides the camera through an open battlefield. 

Unfortunately, it's hopelessly mechanical. I couldn't help shake the feeling that I was merely being a cameraman, dutifully pushing a camera dolly to the next perfectly framed shot. It's then that you start to see the puppeteer's strings, the trigger points for events. Everything falls into place so neatly, it shatters the illusion that this is a living, breathing battlefield where anything can happen. "Anything" never does, unless it is scripted to do so. 

Infinity Ward treats the campaign as sort of an endgame to the old school hardcore game design of bigger and better. Any sense of dynamics is provided under strict authorial control, which is both admirable, and also quite frankly, a bit predictable. The trick of giving first person camera control to different characters (recalling the presidential assassination stage from part one) is reused, sometimes to great effect like the controversial level in which the player goes undercover in a terror cell's attack on a civilian airport. But the rest often falls flat, especially since Infinity Ward seems to be confused on deciding what kind of story they want to tell.

Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Screenshot

Some levels, notably the American-based ones, are all about the logistics of the battle. It's about the guy next to you, it's about being told what to do and not asking any questions. It would work if the game kept with this chilly, forlorn mood. Ridley Scott's film Black Hawk Down remains a powerful narrative without any one character dominating it. But the other levels are saddled in the yippee-ki-yay upbeat tones that draw the Bruckheimer comparisons including out-of-place one-liners, sloganeering, Saturday morning cartoon villainy, and madcap impossible escapes of explosions not seen since, well, a few weeks ago with Uncharted 2's Nathan Drake.

So is Modern Warfare 2 a statement, or pure fantasy? It's pure fantasy, for sure, and the developers are likely to agree—but there are inklings of the single-player campaign aspiring to be so much more. The storytelling, however, lacks clarity of thought and vision, which brings up another question of whether Infinity Ward won't take it further, or maybe they simply lack the eloquence. 

Whatever the case may be, the game is also a statement on Infinity Ward's strengths. Every trailer they released was not just promotional material, it was sabre-rattling to other publishers, daring them to release another game this week. And it worked. The holiday season is noticeably bare, and Modern Warfare 2 stands tall, with its brilliant, value-packed missions, maps, and promised endless nights of thousand-yard stares and slack-jawed home entertainment. It is a commanding presence in living room electronics. 

But most importantly, it's a powerful affirmation for those who define games less as art, and more as a sport of group dynamics that fuels the innate necessity of "must play" human contest. There is no greater argument. Rating: 8.0 out of 10.

Disclosures: This game was obtained via retail purchase and reviewed on the Xbox 360. Approximately 10 hours of play was devoted to single-player modes (completed twice) and 18 hours of play in multiplayer modes.

Parents: According to the ESRB, this game contains blood, drug references, intense violence and language. The violence is not over the top, but realistic. The biggest red flag is an early mission in the game where the player is party to a terrorist attack on a Russian airport, where dozens of innocents are murdered.

Deaf & Hard of Hearing: All essential dialogue is subtitled, though some of the radio chatter is not. Minor audio cues that let the player know where the enemies are coming from are usually not represented, but the game does a good job of guiding the player's eyes anyway.

Latest posts by Gene Park (see all)

Leave a Reply

20 Comments on "Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2 Review"

Notify of
avatar

Sort by:   newest | oldest
RandomRob
Guest
RandomRob
6 years 7 months ago

You seem like, really angry.. maybe Anonymity isn’t really your thing.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous
6 years 7 months ago
[quote=RandomRob][quote=matt]What planet are you living on? Im pretty sure the market is flooded with good games at the moment. This site is pretty cynical and bitter though, so I could see how their might not be that many good games in your eyes.[/quote] Flooded? I own a PS3 and have already bought Demons Souls so that leaves Assassins Creed 2 after I rule out MW2 on account of a 5 hour single player campaign. For me, that’s one game to look forward to before xmas, so I dont agree with you. Nor with your assessment of this site. I like… Read more »
Gene P.
Guest
Gene P.
6 years 8 months ago

Uhh. The industry itself has acknowledged that the holiday season is lacking in big hitters. All the big publishers have already made their case in the past two weeks. That’s it for Christmas man.

It’s a well-documented fact that many publishers pushed back releasing their big hitters because of the recession, and having to compete with the likes of Modern Warfare 2.

RandomRob
Guest
RandomRob
6 years 8 months ago
[quote=matt]What planet are you living on? Im pretty sure the market is flooded with good games at the moment. This site is pretty cynical and bitter though, so I could see how their might not be that many good games in your eyes.[/quote] Flooded? I own a PS3 and have already bought Demons Souls so that leaves Assassins Creed 2 after I rule out MW2 on account of a 5 hour single player campaign. For me, that’s one game to look forward to before xmas, so I dont agree with you. Nor with your assessment of this site. I like… Read more »
matt
Guest
matt
6 years 8 months ago

“The holiday season is noticeably bare, and Modern Warfare 2 stands tall…”. What planet are you living on? Im pretty sure the market is flooded with good games at the moment. This site is pretty cynical and bitter though, so I could see how their might not be that many good games in your eyes.

Snosrap
Guest
Snosrap
6 years 8 months ago
I’m sure I’ll log my fair share of time online in multiplayer. It would just be nice to see Infinity Ward come through with an equally great campaign experience. I got hooked on FPS’s with the Halo series and no game has captured the campaign experience better IMO in a FPS. I’m not looking for sandbox- just some choice, and you just don’t get any of that in Infinity Ward games (as well as Epic Games). The argument for the linear nature of the game is story telling and cinematography – great, go to Hollywood and make a movie Infinity… Read more »
Gene P.
Guest
Gene P.
6 years 8 months ago

If I could somehow command all game reviews to review each part of a game separately, then I assure you, Modern Warfare 2’s multiplayer would get a perfect 10 or 100 or five stars, or whatever.

Unfortunately the single player is part of the game, and there’s nothing I can do to change that. As one poster said earlier, he doesn’t know why Infinity Ward even bothers with it, and after MW2, I am inclined to agree.

Gene P.
Guest
Gene P.
6 years 8 months ago
Hi Andrew, thanks for your comments. I honestly don’t feel my score is low at all. I wish there was a way I could post the overall review scale GameCritics.com has here, but as we’ve explained over and over again, we love to use the entire 1 through 10 scale. If I gave Modern Warfare 2 an 8, that means I believe it’s an amazing game that is a must play for fans of the genre or series. A four-star film from a major newspaper translates to an “80” on Metacritic. And I don’t think anyone can argue that a… Read more »
Chi Kong Lui
Guest
Chi Kong Lui
6 years 8 months ago

[quote=andrew n.]Lastly, artistic value is all fine and dandy but what it boils down to is that just because this game isn’t Bioshock doesn’t mean that it wasn’t made with the highest degree of care and attention to detail and to accomplish the goal universal among video games: which is to be fun.[/quote] It’s funny, but I posted this comment at the same time as you: Fun is meaningless.

andrew n.
Guest
andrew n.
6 years 8 months ago
I don’t understand why metacritic is posting your score as 80/100 when it isn’t stated in a numerical fashion on the review itself. Secondly, most people don’t spend the entire single player campaign inching through levels to see which where and to what effect the invisible lines trigger new events; this is because part of the game experience that they’re going for is a measure of cinematography and honestly I can’t say that going nonlinear is really all that helpful in making a really rich and compelling experience. I mean in theory it sounds awesome but I’ve found that it… Read more »
Mr D
Guest
Mr D
6 years 8 months ago
I was bored with the multiplayer in mw1 after the first week. I don’t see how the multiplayer in mw2 would be any more engaging. I’ll stick with l4d as that actually uses real teamwork and is a very satisfying game for months, or bf2 which has been great for 3 years. I can’t believe they are charging 60 dollars for this game on pc, I’ve never seen any pc game be more than 50. Why the change? And with the elimination of dedicated servers I really have no faith in the longevity of this game for me. l4d could… Read more »
Li-Ion
Guest
Li-Ion
6 years 8 months ago
I personally don’t give a flying sh*t about multiplayer. Neither do a lot of people. Don’t make the mistake of projecting your preferences and personal surroundings to the rest of the world. I’ll get MW2 later this week and might even check out the spec ops mode. But apart from that the singleplayer experience is my main interest. If it doesn’t deliver there, the game fails for me and in this case I wouldn’t see a point in rating it as high as it is. If it would be a multiplayer-only title I wouldn’t care, since I’d not spend money… Read more »
OJ
Guest
OJ
6 years 8 months ago
Guys, in todays gaming world, its all about MULIPLAYER. Even if MW2’s campaign mode was not linear, and was lets say 20 hours long it still cannot compare to months- even years of multiplayer action. So my main point is, you cannot rate this game so poorly it just talks bad for your judgement! I’ve been a gamer since 1987, if you are a FPS fan this is truely the most enganging, with the most beatifully crafted visuals , most rewarding, FPS action packed game you could have hoped for! If you don’t have Xbox live, do yourself a huge… Read more »
Snosrap
Guest
Snosrap
6 years 8 months ago

Why Infinity-Ward bothers to add campaigns to their games is beyond me. All of the COD games have been total rail shooters. Go here, trip that invisible trigger kill somebody. Go there, set explosives. I’m board. Multiplayer on the other hand is very enjoyable. I think Infinity-Ward should hire an AI programmer, it is 2009 after all. Their campaign game design is circa 1985 with updated graphics.

Jacob Harris
Guest
Jacob Harris
6 years 8 months ago

This is the first review for this game I have read all the way through, Straight to the point and very useful. I have got this game, and I think the score may be a little harsh, but I understand why he gave it what it got. As this is my first CoD, I am obviously more amazed by everything, but I do understand that the common (non fanboy) opinion is that it is largely the same as 4. glad to see a review not with the droves (Also you are the joint lowest score on Metacritic)

Dale Weir
Guest
Dale Weir
6 years 8 months ago

[quote=Jeremy]Uh, both of those screenshots are CLEARLY from COD4, not MW2.[/quote]We’ve updated the screenshots.

abfackeln
Guest
abfackeln
6 years 8 months ago

[quote=Jeremy]Uh, both of those screenshots are CLEARLY from COD4, not MW2.[/quote]

I was going to say the same thing.

Gene, I was hoping that you would write a review. Good job.

Jeremy
Guest
6 years 8 months ago

Uh, both of those screenshots are CLEARLY from COD4, not MW2.

Ken San Nicolas
Guest
Ken San Nicolas
6 years 8 months ago

As much as I hate to say it, this is a very good review, Gene. Your writing is incredibly accurate and you put into words exactly what I wanted to say. Well, I mean even better than I could write it certainly. PM me your gamertag.

Mike D
Guest
Mike D
6 years 8 months ago
Fantastic review Gene. It’s refreshing not to have to slog through a four-page feature-by-feature dissection of the game; you get right to the meat of the experience, which is exactly what good criticism should do. I guess if I were more a multiplayer fanatic I’d be more interested in the title. $60 seems like a lot of cash to plunk down for a five-hour, linear campaign. It’s the linearity and inflexibility of CoD’s campaigns that’s always turned me off; I mean, I enjoy a good thrill ride too, and I do enjoy the series, but I don’t hold them in… Read more »
wpDiscuz