Re: Post here when you beat a game. I mean it!
A few weeks ago I completed Red Dead Redemption (not 100% mind you, just enough to complete the story) and had the same opinion of many others. Too many sidequests crammed in, making the game feel slightly superficial. A few weeks have past and I think the game is slightly overrated. The story was passable, but nothing fantastic and overly cliched.
I also completed Braid again, which I purchased on the PS3. I completely forgot all the answers to the puzzle, and made it an easier game to replay.