Re: Please rate this review-Mirror's Edge
This would make a great forum post. A great review, not so much. It's entertaining, but it's lacking a strong concept, lacking exposition, and it doesn't follow any of our formatting rules.
This is one of those cases where to me, it's not quite worth it to go point-by-point addressing what's not working, because there's just not enough to work with. Instead, I recommend you read more reviews — here at our site, at edge-online.com, and of course at the big commercial sites like IGN. Our reviews don't need to be a feature-by-feature dissections like the commercial sites do, but those site can give you a better grasp on the writing process in general.