[idiotic]

That's a very good review Luke - it's written especially well.

The only thing I would add is PooP's surprising indebtedness to other games - like Ico and Shadow of the Colossus, and to a lesser extent, Okami. Perhaps what is most surprising is that the original PoP was an influence on Ico, and this version seems to rep(l)ay the compliment by copying Ico in arguably an insulting way.

If you acknowledge these debts and critically comment on how well PooP p(l)ays it, I would also insert a green thumb up your bum.