GameCritics.com Forums

GameCritics.com Forums (http://www.gamecritics.com/forums/index.php)
-   Community User Submissions (http://www.gamecritics.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   Final Fantasy VIII Review (http://www.gamecritics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=20176)

holdthephone 11-08-2012 03:35 PM

Rate this Review: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
Final Fantasy VIII Review
Squaresoft

HIGH: The first disc.

LOW: Party split ups.

WTF: The entire game.

Squall is nearing the end of his studies at Balamb Garden, a campus host to mercenary youths who study combat skills and magic as everyday course material. Here, girls can still be found gossiping in hallways, and boys picking fights over petty insecurities. For Squall, those childish urges leave him a scar, a nasty gash across the face from a rival classmate’s gunblade, the weapon itself a true representation of the bizarre balancing act that is Final Fantasy VIII. Where realistic and familiar components – a blade and revolver -- combine to make something new and incomprehensible.


In its attempt to mesh the realities of high school life and military regiment, Final Fantasy VIII creates a premise -- like the gunblade -- beyond belief, but of rich fantasy. Squall’s first mission is actually just part of his school’s curriculum, a field exam where students raid the beaches of a city under military occupation. The whole segment is a complete rush, battle screen to battle screen as heroic music bites at your heels, although afterward, it’s back at school with an impatient and obnoxious group of kids, waiting in corridors for test results to be posted.

The game is often surreal in this way, a sort of boyhood fantasy come to life. Daringly realistic in its depiction of the growing pains of youth, but wholly unreasonable in the situations it places its cast of young adults. Childish moments during grisly missions may have you ready to flip the nearest table in disgust, and there are many. These youths showcase no qualifications to be soldiers, just the naivety of their age. Only when they are linked with what’s called a Guardian Force do they become a group capable of saving the world.

These guardian beasts form what’s called a Junction with their human counterparts, opening up customization options for your party. Of these, the Draw command serves most valuable, since in Final Fantasy VIII, enemies hold the magic. Drawing allows you to steal spells that when stored can be attached to the stat sheets of your party members. A turn based system under an active time frame; you must decide when to pull magic, and when to deal damage. The more you collect of a spell, the more it benefits the stats of say, Strength, Magic, or elemental modifiers to your strikes.


Drawing is rather gratifying, both in its colorful, sucking animation on the battle screen, and how it makes your characters stronger in the menus afterward. But it's also daunting. Each person can hold a 100 of each type of spell, so collecting maximum amounts of Fires, Blizzards, Cures, and others can become a nightmarish grind if you pursue it. And when many creatures don’t bear much in the way of teeth, you don’t really have an excuse not to drink your fill from their temptingly infinite reserves.

Addicting, perhaps -- raising your stats to premature levels of dominance -- but the system’s fragility will take a toll on your experience in one way or another. Powerful spells can be collected at certain points in the game, such as the Life magic that can triple your party’s HP amounts early on. Savvy players that figure such tactics out will later find themselves facing encounters of little value, where in fact it’s smarter to run away as leveling scales you with the rest of the game’s enemies.

Conversely, those who can’t wrap their head around the freedoms of the Junction system will end up either drawing everything in sight, or clinging to what works early on – summoning. This means calling an actual Guardian Force, thus a torturous, 20-30 second long cinematic attack. With Junctioning stats being the more rewarding and effective way to power, it’s odd the game tries to push you towards a reliance on summons at the start, providing little in the way of helpful hints to playing properly. Enjoyment is instead dependent on player strategy, both an intimidating and refreshing idea, and luckily for some not a huge focus. Large dungeons are in fact nearly non-existent, so rarely does the system get laborious.


The typical cast of intolerable child heroes also seem to have a ghost of presence, largely ignored by both Squall and the game. Never of primary concern, it’s as if they exist to annoy the main character. Squall is a blunt professional who hates small talk and petty social obligations, and to great relief of likely most players, he becomes agitated when you would. A relatable and adult minded person placed in absurd situations, he points out the very outrageousness of the game around him. When you feel like facepalming, you may be surprised to see Squall do so first.

Taking advantage of this amusement, the game is primarily comprised of light hearted skits, scenes of dialogue that move with very lifelike animation, obtuse Japanese humor, and fantastical set pieces. It runs with its imagination and never looks back, rampantly day dreaming. Here is a world where simple fishing towns reside on one continent, and futuristic cities, hover cars, and fluent space programs on another. It introduces huge plot elements at the drop of hat, nonchalantly informing you about its theories of telepathy, time compression, and out of body experiences. At one moment you’ll be hijacking speeding trains with a group of rebel misfits, and the next shooting up to orbit.

Yet often too fantastical to believe, the game seems eerily aware of its own incredibility. Even its soundtrack -- of Uematsu's best work -- is a combination of the dreamy and nightmarish. It hides something beneath its outlandish narrative and unorthodox battle strategy, something more real and down to earth. That is, a clear inspection of an introverted young adult. As if using its fictional qualities to disguise its true intentions, the game drapes Squall and the player underneath its decorative wings of fantasy. As you both take note of its unbelievable nature, you are gradually being lured out as subjects of study.


Beckoning you from your RPG is a girl, the romantic interest that takes hold of Squall’s life. She defines Final Fantasy VIII not merely as a love story, but rather as the theatrical, musical, and visual trip it is. She resides in it as the game’s obsession, the idée fixe that tears apart the mind of a man forced into a heroic role without the mental strength to succeed in it. Always challenging his cold approach and mathematical demeanor, she annoys him as much as the others do, but relentlessly and adorably. Dismissing her as well as his own feelings, Squall takes her presence for granted; eventually finding himself uncharacteristically bereaved when she is placed in danger.

In this telling scene, Squall’s crew is again ranting on about the insanely crafted conundrum of a plot that surrounds them, but here the screen fades to dark. Dialogue boxes continue to pester your view, but now scatter around Squall’s thoughts. His appear squarely at the center of the screen, and are clear: this girl is all that matters now. And from here to the end, his battles will be fought over a regretful conscience. As he reaches for her the game becomes more and more incredulous, to the point of utter psychosis as you face villainess witches that drip with personal foreboding. The finale -- a chilling introspection to a repressed mind.


Indeed, there’s something about the girl named Rinoa Heartily. The way she ardently struts towards your removed world of fantasy, invading it with her dark eyes and conceited smile. Pressuring you into decisions and confrontations throughout the game, she drags you from the comforts of role playing escapism and into self-analysis. In a world of elite magical soldiers, evil sorceresses, brilliant mythical beasts and time travel, she remains tangible. A comforting constant within a schizophrenic universe, she pulls you by the arm towards emotional clarity. Onto the ballroom floor and into the spotlight, “I can’t dance” isn’t a response she’ll accept.

8.5/10

Disclosure: This game was obtained via digital retail and reviewed on the PS3 platform. Approximately 45 hours of play were devoted to the game

Parents: Rated T for Teen, for "Mild language, suggestive themes, violence."

Deaf and Hard of Hearing: Accessible, written dialogue.

RandomRob 11-08-2012 04:03 PM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
nice to see a fresh take on this game! It was always compared to VII and never really judged on it's merits, imo. Great review :cool:

holdthephone 11-08-2012 05:14 PM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
Yeah I tried to avoid any sort of comparison to the rest of the franchise (since I don't see how it's relevant). Glad you enjoyed it.

RandomRob 11-08-2012 05:40 PM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
first time you played it?

holdthephone 11-08-2012 06:59 PM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
Yup, looking to get to others I've missed out on too.

Pedro 11-10-2012 02:52 PM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
Wow, really good review. It is almost a feature rather than a review, but I like your style and it's a really interesting take (I haven't played the game).

I hate to nitpick, but your language got a little away from you in the penultimate paragraph :)

conscious = conscience?
incredulous = incredible?
introspection = insight?

Sorry about that! really good stuff though.

Rob, you are a moderator; can you twist these guys arms and get them looking at the community submissions again?

RandomRob 11-10-2012 03:44 PM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
I can bother them ;) But Holdthephone, do yourself a favor, title your reviews 'RATE THIS REVIEW: Final Fantasy VIII'.. just to make sure they know you're serious.

holdthephone 11-10-2012 03:48 PM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
Thanks for being active on this boards pedro, always appreciate the feedback.

I changed the title but I don't know, I figure people rate them anyways, lol.

RandomRob 11-10-2012 07:36 PM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
titling it 'rate this review' is more of a polite nod to the admins to have a look. Not canon, but it helps.

JLB1987 11-11-2012 03:07 AM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
yep, great review. You have me wanting to play this again (first played it in my teens, remember giving up at a station type place where you had to kill a bunch of stuff in pairs, according to colour or something- my teenage self couldn't be fucked with that, lol). Can't really fault this review- four stars from me. Good read.

RandomRob 11-11-2012 06:25 AM

Re: Final Fantasy VIII Review
 
Actually picking up my last playthrough and going through some of it again. The combat system has definitely aged well, and the game environment has less of those 'wtf do I do NOW' moments than FF VII. Maybe VIII was ahead of it's time?


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright 1999-2010 GameCritics.com. All rights reserved.