About Us | Game Reviews | Feature Articles | Podcast | Best Work | Forums | Shop | Review Game

Quick note on Alan Wake review response

Brad Gallaway's picture

Alan Wake Screenshot

Alan Wake is certainly not a terrible title, but it is repetitive and fairly underwhelming—doubly so for a game that's been in development for more than five years. I give credit to the developers for some beautiful environments and a combat style that's sensible and engaging, but it's weak in most other areas. I also have to say that for a game that's been so heavily touted for its story, I found the plot to be poorly-structured and unsatisfying.

(A side note to you preemptive Alan Wake fanboys who've been posting negative remarks on the review: At least have the decency to wait until the game hits retail before tearing my evaluation down. If you've got a reason to disagree with me, I'd love to hear it. Present your case. Tell me your rationale. I'm honestly interested. However, you really don't have a thing to say until you've actually played the game, you "every other site gave it a 9" tossers.)

In other games news, I've been spending a bit of time with Retro (mini) on PlayStation Portable. It's a new take on the old formula where players pilot a ship of some sort through obstacles and caves while struggling against gravity. I think the first game of its type ever played was Solar Jetman way back on the NES, and this isn't much different. However, although it's not reinventing the wheel, it's got a clean presentation and it handles well. If you've got an itch for this sort of thing, I think it will be pretty well scratched.

Also just finished off the Blue Toad Murder Files series on PSN with the wife. My review of the first three (of six) chapters is right here. Although it's lean on gameplay, a few of the puzzles are bogus, and the story isn't as tight as it could be, I admit that I had a soft spot for the dialogue and characters. Some of that stuff just completely cracks me up. The butcher? Pure gold. If the game was a little more robust in terms of how many puzzles were offered and had the multiplayer tweaked, I would have no problem recommending it to others. As it stands, it's fairly flawed, though there's a lot to like if you dig kooky cut scenes.

One final bit on games, I was quite lucky this week and won a copy of Monster Hunter Tri from GameZone in one of their contests.

Though I'm totally in love with the concept of hunting giant monsters, my experience with the original PlayStation 2 Monster Hunter was quite negative and I couldn't possibly conceive of any way the follow-up PSP version could have possibly been worth my time. Even so, I still think the concept is golden and reviews of Tri have been very favorable. I'm really hoping that Capcom has tweaked the formula enough to finally deliver the goods. At this point, I wasn't convinced enough to put my own money down on it, but I will most definitely put a free copy through its paces.

Category Tags
Platform(s): Xbox 360  
Developer(s): Remedy  
Series: Alan Wake  
Genre(s): Shooting  

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

does the word "tosser" have

does the word "tosser" have the same meaning in the states as it does here in england? your use of it made me laugh.

to buy alan wake or not too...

I haven't always agreed with

I haven't always agreed with your reviews Brad, but I do respect that you are one of the very few reviewers who has the courage to review a game exactly as you see it.

Just remember that it's much better to be hated for reviewing a game low, than it is for rating it too highly.

People don't have to play

People don't have to play the game to knock the review. Don't you remember? You're a "statistical outlier." lol

Wrong, so wrong

I was lucky enough to get my hands on a copy of Alan Wake 2 weeks before launch due to a retail blunder.

Let me preface this by saying that Alan Wake made me feel like a little kid trapped in a dark room with monsters crawling under my bed. I had nightmares. And I loved every minute of it.

The nostalgia this brought me back to, the days of Silent Hill and Resident Evil, that isolated feeling, that helpless feeling.

Not only the feeling of fear, it was the feeling of immersion. Remedy did an amazing job of making every little detail of the game world come alive. I actually felt part of this small Northwest.

The gameplay is tight, the different scenarios you're thrown into feels fresh, and the light mechanic works in more was than you'd imagine.

And dont even get me started on the lighting of this game. It is UNCANNY.

I can honestly say that I have played this game through. I sat down every night and played with my surround sound, in the dark. If you played this on your 23 inch screen at your desk, I recommend replaying it.

After reading this review, I can honestly say that the accuracy is a complete miss. Maybe next time.

techRELIC wrote: I was

techRELIC wrote:

I was lucky enough to get my hands on a copy of Alan Wake 2 weeks before launch due to a retail blunder.

Ok, seems that everyone and his dog got this game 'somehow' weeks before release. I don't buy it, sorry. I've never seen a game where so many claimed to have played it already weeks before release, and that reviewers that have something to complain about get it all wrong. On Eurogamer there are now almost 800 comments on the review (rating 7/10, same as EDGE magazines 7/10), and many of them from people who are just missing the point of a review. When you claim a review is wrong, you're missing the point. A review is and always will be an opinion. There is nothing like absolute objectivity, only perception. In case of comments on EG there is of course a lot of sexism involved, after all it was a woman who reviewed the game and apparently women are 'not getting' Alan Wake.

Also these games don't appeal to everyone in the same way. You mention Resident Evil. I never got what's special about Resident Evil. I found the first was Alone in the Dark with Zombies and laughable voice acting. The only other RE game I played was 4, which I found ok, but it had clunky controls in my opinion. I'm baffled how the controls are considered by some to improve the game somehow...

"retail blunder" means he

"retail blunder" means he pirated it. There's been copies of it floating around for a while now, sadly.

Totally agree

I played Alan Wake yesterday for a couple of hours and I was really disappointed.

I would expect a much more better title for an exclusive XBOX360 title and a game that has been developed for 5 years.

I don't see why the five

I don't see why the five year development time has anything to do with people's expectations. Games are often notoriously late, and if anything, after five years, it doesn't surprise me Remedy have played it safe. Alan Wake is polished, yes, but it doesn't reinvent the wheel. Why is anyone surprised?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Code of Conduct

Comments are subject to approval/deletion based on the following criteria:
1) Treat all users with respect.
2) Post with an open-mind.
3) Do not insult and/or harass users.
4) Do not incite flame wars.
5) Do not troll and/or feed the trolls.
6) No excessive whining and/or complaining.

Please report any offensive posts here.

For more video game discussion with the our online community, become a member of our forum.

Our Game Review Philosophy and Ratings Explanations.

About Us | Privacy Policy | Review Game | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook |  RSS
Copyright 1999–2010 GameCritics.com. All rights reserved.