About Us | Game Reviews | Feature Articles | Podcast | Best Work | Forums | Shop | Review Game

Monday Night Combat, and Too Human... doesn't suck. An Open Apology.

Brad Gallaway's picture

So Monday Night Combat is out. If you haven't taken a look, check out the free demo available on Live.

Despite having one of the longest and most tiring days in recent memory, I was able to get a couple hours in before falling asleep. While I'm usually a solo player, this is definitely a game that benefits from having real teammates, and I was fortunate enough to jump into a group where almost everyone knew each other.

To be sure, the meat of the experience is had in the 6-on-6 Crossfire mode. Having live players to go up against while trying to take out the enemy's money ball was a great time, and although I tend to favor the Tank class, I was having quite a bit of fun with the Sniper. I hope to spend some more time with it this week, but based on my experience this evening, I would really only want to do it with people I knew. I can't imagine it would be half as fun with strangers.

Then again, that's pretty true for just about any game, isn't it?

Too Human Screenshot

In what is likely to be the biggest, most unexpected surprise of the year (for me, anyway) GameCritics Podcast host @TimSpaeth finally convinced the rest of us to partake in a group play/discussion on 360's Too Human for an upcoming episode.

What was the surprising part? I actually liked it.

If you've ever listened to the podcast, you've probably heard Tim talk about Too Human, or at least mention it. In fact, it gets brought up so often that it's basically a running gag on the show.

The rest of us have ribbed him about his love for the title dozens of times, and he's always taken it in good humor. However, I think that we all assumed he was slightly crazy. After all, Too Human took a serious critical beating when it was released, to the point that it was almost an industry punchline. A large part of that had to do with a general reaction to Silicon Knights' head man Dennis Dyack on a personal level, but it's still common to ask people what they think of the game apart from Dyack and get a negative response. The words "garbage" or "worthless" are descriptors that come up a lot in conversations I've had.

To be perfectly honest, I was dreading having to play the game after hearing so much bad about it. I figured I'd put in a half an hour, vomit in a bucket, and then think up some more jokes at Tim's expense. However, that's not what happened. Not at all.

While the game is certainly unconventional in several ways, I have to say that it didn't have much difficulty grabbing my interest and I was actually quite fascinated with some of the choices on display—things like the new take on a classic hack-and-slash control scheme, or the way the game has reinterpreted Norse myths into cyberspace metaphors. It's pretty clever, really.

Oh, and the loot? It falls like rain in a monsoon season.

Too Human's a perfect example of a concept that should appeal to a lot of players (Norse myths as cybertech—in a hack-and-slash!!)  but I can understand how the final, gotta-chew-on-it expression of that concept would catch some people off guard. However, after putting three hours into it, I was actually wondering how so many people who reviewed it ended up being so negative. It's certainly different, but I haven't seen anything that was outright bad or wrong. So far, anyway.

After having said all that, I do feel as though I owe both Too Human and Tim an apology—I'm definitely a believer in trying things before you talk and I've spent my review career giving underdogs the benefit of the doubt, but this is absolutely one time when I was too complacent. In Too Human's case, I was content to trust the consensus and go along with the crowd, and that was wrong. I'm certainly not proud.

Mea culpa.

Category Tags
Platform(s): Xbox 360   PS3  
Developer(s): Silicon Knights   Uber Entertainment  
Series: Too Human  
Genre(s): Shooting  

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

All Hail King Spaeth

I remember back when I played Too Human, I was the recipient of more insults than I care to mention since I really liked the game.

I realize the game does have a few buggy elements, the targeting is a little difficult to figure out at first, and the stick based combat is very different from what most hack and slash games have been in the past (hint, don't hold the stick in one direction). I notice that in most games the skills you get are of the vanilla "do more damage" variety, and while too human has plenty of this each class I tried gave the player a specific advantage (such as longer in air combos) and allowed for significantly different play styles to emerge especially in the online component. Of course, as you mentioned Too Human really nails the loot game.

All in all I felt that Too Human is one of those games that doesn't necessarily bring revolutionary innovations to the table but adds it's own flair to the formula. Perhaps it is due to the long development time, and the switch from the playstation 2, to xbox, to xbox 360 throwing a wrench in the code base that the systems don't work perfectly.

Hack and slash games have always had the same formula where a is jump, x is a light attack, Y is heavy, and so on, and here is where Too Human's fault lies. It is one of those games that hits progression, loot and all the other marks that players love, but is unfortunate enough to reside in a genre whose fans are extremely resistant to change.

Too Human doesn't suck for me at least

"I remember back when I played Too Human, I was the recipient of more insults than I care to mention since I really liked the game."

That sucks! Although I'm sorry to admit I actually found that really amusing as well!

Just started playing this game a couple days ago and am 20 hours into it and I liked it overall so far. One can really nerd out with spec'ing and with armor and weapons, similar to Borderlands in many respects. There are some annoying glitches and I don't really like the way the game handles the camera during battles, but overall I too am surprised the game received such poor reviews.

Kudos to you!

A lot of us TH fans have been through the same wringer that you put your friend Tim through. Good on you for putting in the time to learn that your initial impressions were incorrect, and based more on groupthink than on any firsthand experience.

I liked Too Human a lot - while it has its fair share of flaws and overall was just too short, it was unique and different and interesting and it TOOK RISKS. A lot of those risks didn't pay off, but you have to give Silicon Knights credit for taking them in the first place. The industry in general - and the hack & slash action RPG genre in particular - is all too formulaic these days, as you noted, so it's cool to see a company willing to break convention.

And frankly, the TH reviewing fiasco is emblematic of all that is wrong with gaming criticism these days. Too many people reviewing the developer and not the game, fawning over the big names (Bioware, Epic, Valve) and taking easy shots at the little guys. I'd like to see more reviewers like yourself who weren't afraid to admit error, or were at least willing to put in the time playing a game to write a review that's actually based on experience, rather than on what all the other reviews are saying.

Hey Jay (and everybody

Hey Jay (and everybody else).

Thanks very much for the comments, I really appreciate it.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Code of Conduct

Comments are subject to approval/deletion based on the following criteria:
1) Treat all users with respect.
2) Post with an open-mind.
3) Do not insult and/or harass users.
4) Do not incite flame wars.
5) Do not troll and/or feed the trolls.
6) No excessive whining and/or complaining.

Please report any offensive posts here.

For more video game discussion with the our online community, become a member of our forum.

Our Game Review Philosophy and Ratings Explanations.

About Us | Privacy Policy | Review Game | Contact Us | Twitter | Facebook |  RSS
Copyright 1999–2010 GameCritics.com. All rights reserved.