The Ultimate Epilogue

Mass Effect 3 Screenshot

HIGH The final battles leading up to the game's end.

LOW Getting unexpectedly locked out of some missions.

WTF Why couldn't I import my old Shepard's appearance?

Although it's not often mentioned, a thing role-playing game (RPG) fans love is when a game takes the time to wrap up loose ends. Since titles in the genre commonly run for extended lengths, it's natural that players grow attached to teammates, supporting characters, enemies and others over the course of their adventures. Finding out what happens to each one is important, and closure is cherished after spending so many hours with them.

While the trailers of aliens invading Earth prior to the game's release were suitably epic and ostensibly intended to draw in new players, I think the ad campaign was at odds with the reality that Mass Effect 3 is hardly Gears of War with spaceships. Newcomers craving bullet-fueled heroics will be talked to death and confused by potential cameos, references to past events, and revelations that may occur with little context. However, for those who've got history with Commander Shepard & crew, Mass Effect 3 is one of the longest and most thorough epilogues in the history of video games.

Like the previous entries, Mass Effect 3 is a third-person shooter/RPG hybrid with squad-based battles that take place in real time. The situation? The cold, insectile Reapers from the furthest reaches of the universe have returned to harvest all organic life, and the situation is grim. Civilizations are falling one by one, and these seemingly unstoppable invaders have extinction on their minds. Our hero must take to the stars and rally all available support for the final battle.

While the premise of gathering resources for a galaxy-spanning conflict is exactly the same as it was in Shepard's previous outing, Mass Effect 3 wisely does away with the overdone "loyalty quest" structure of the last game. In doing so, it avoids feeling like a mess of disparate episodes despite bringing back nearly every character that's ever appeared. The trick is that instead of each having their own sidestory, they're all woven into a central narrative that has clear purpose, strong pace, and sharp focus. Although I can't say letting the Reapers land on earth within the first ten minutes of gameplay was an idea that worked for me (it hardly looks like the people of Earth will survive an hour while Shepard traipses back and forth across star systems) our hero now has concrete motivation for doing what gets done and the writing, on the whole, is of excellent quality.

Along the way, reconnecting with old squaddies and finding out where they ended up is handled beautifully. It's this quality that makes the game such a fantastic endpiece to the series, and to players like myself who want to know what became of this teammate or what happened after that choice, Mass Effect 3 delivers by the truckload. In fact, it's this completeness and that leaves me puzzled about the raging furor over the final few minutes of the game. While I can understand that some non-negotiable plot points at story's end weren't as tight as they should have been and weren't to everyone's taste, they're hardly a tick on the twenty to thirty hours of meticulous wrap-up that came before.

Mass Effect 3 Screenshot

Story and characters aside, I'm happy to report that BioWare has made several tweaks to the game's technical aspects. While skill trees for each character could be more diverse and setting up the team's gear is still too streamlined, it does feel as though some meat has returned to the bones thanks to reasonably generous options for tweaking Shepard's powers, armor and weapons. Even better, while the loathsome planet-scanning is still a factor in many smaller quests, it's been modified and sped up to be less painful. It's still not as enjoyable as touching down on a random planet to search for surprises on my own, but it dovetails appropriately with the urgency of the plot and is a clear step up from scanning in Mass Effect 2.

The retooled combat in Mass Effect 3 is also worthy of praise. While handling characters feels essentially unchanged from the last game, the level designs and conceptualization of combat are an order of magnitude better than the relentless corridor shootouts of Mass Effect 2. A few narrow hallways still manage to rear their heads, but a healthy diversity of architecture is on display, not to mention skirmish scenarios that have the player performing different tasks while under fire—things like guarding certain areas or pulling off critical objectives. I wouldn't come to Mass Effect if I was after serious gunplay, but the shooting stays fresh for the length of the campaign and even manages to deliver some jaw-dropping sequences along the way. It is, by far, the best action this series has ever seen.

As for the widely-publicized multiplayer mode, I'd say that not only is it unnecessary, it actually hurts the overall quality of the game. Why? Mass Effect 3's best ending must be earned by accumulating assets, and the missions to get them are tedious fetchquests. Little effort was made to spice them up, and my guess is they're intentionally bland to encourage players who want "the good ending" to partake of the multiplayer mode—by going online, players can reduce the number of snoozeworthy missions that must be completed.

While the cooperative wave-based combat works exactly as one might expect it to, the majority of character customization options are locked (including basic weapon selection) and can only be earned by purchasing "packs" of unlocks. The player can earn in-game credits for these, but it takes a long time to do so and the things they unlock are random.

See the plan here? Singleplayer ending-related missions are boring, so players go online to avoid completing them. Once they're online, they pay real cash via microtransactions to speed up the unlocking process and customize the experience. Frankly, this overt milking doesn't belong in a triple-A RPG. I'd have rather seen multiplayer skipped altogether and those resources put towards making the campaign's asset gathering richer and more engaging.

Although I would never say that Mass Effect 3 was a perfect game, joining Commander Shepard and the rest of the crew has been an incredible experience spanning three titles and five years. There have been stumbles along the way, but I can't think of another series that's been so full of crucial, nail-biting decisions or the sort of emotional moments that have stayed with me over time. As someone who made friends with telepathic spiders, destroyed a giant Terminator, and romanced a blue alien with tentacles for hair, I genuinely feel that BioWare has delivered the most comprehensive epilogue that an RPG fan like me could have hoped for. My hat is off to them for being able to bring this hugely ambitious project to such a satisfactory conclusion, and I hope the overall quality of this work is indicative of what we can expect from them in the future. Well done. Rating: 8.5 out of 10.


Disclosures: This game was obtained via publisher and reviewed on the Xbox 360. Approximately 32 hours of play were devoted to the single-player mode, and the game was completed. 3 hours of play were spent in multiplayer modes.

Parents: According to the ESRB, this game contains blood, partial nudity, sexual content, strong language, and violence. Although all of these warning tags are accurate, I don't feel that this game is anywhere near being the most offensive or harmful thing on the market. All of the subject matter is used in the proper context, and the game itself is definitely aimed at mature players. It's a great experience and one that I would recommend… although not to children. Moms and dads, keep the little ones away and play this yourself.

Deaf & Hard of Hearing: There shouldn't be any issues to be concerned about here. Subtitles are available for all dialogue, and even though the combat happens in real-time, I never found any of the audio cues to be important or beneficial. When I couldn't find enemies, it was more effective to watch where my teammates were aiming than it was to try and listen for gunfire. In my opinion, the game should be totally accessible to hearing-impaired players.

Brad Gallaway

Brad Gallaway

Brad Gallaway has been gaming since the days when arcades were everywhere and the Atari 2600 was cutting edge. So, like... A while.

Currently, he's got about 42 minutes a night to play because adulting is a timesuck, but despite that, he's a happily married guy with two kids who both have better K/D ratios than he does.

Brad still loves Transformers, he's on Marvel Puzzle Quest when nobody at the office is looking, and his favorite game of all time is the first Mass Effect -- and he thought the trilogy's ending was Just Fine, Thanks.

Follow Brad on Twitter at @BradGallaway
Brad Gallaway

Latest posts by Brad Gallaway (see all)

Leave a Reply

17 Comments on "Mass Effect 3 Review"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest
Alv
Guest
It’s good, I’m glad I played it. But left with a tinge of disappointment. This game will be remembered as the climax of a gripping 5-year space opera, but does not really stand-up to evolutionary benchmarks set by its predecessors. It simply does not have the polish you would expect of a triple-A title. Indeed it smacks of laziness. i) Conversations that are poorly paced and aren’t cut properly – basic technical issues. ii) Diane Allers – What a poorly considered waste of time and space of a character. iii) Cringeworthy voice-acting esp. from Liara – moreso than previous versions… Read more »
Li-Ion
Guest
before I forget… in the article you linked here yourself: [quote=Lambonius]This is by far the best analysis of the failures of the Mass Effect 3 ending from a story-telling standpoint. http://jmstevenson.wordpress.com/2012/03/22/all-that-matters-is-the-ending-part-2-mass-effect-3/[/quote] There is also mention of the indoctrination theory: [quote=The Writers Block]Now there is a lot of evidence to support this theory, so much in fact, that I think that was the direction Bioware might have been going for. And you know what? That would have been an amazing accomplishment. If they had pulled that off I would be down on my knees praising Bioware as the new Writing Gods,… Read more »
Li-Ion
Guest
Regarding plotholes: indoctrination theory has WAY LESS plotholes than the story would have at this point if the last part wouldn’t be a result of indoctrination. [quote=Lambonius]And if it was the plan all along to release a twist ending via DLC–how is that not WORSE?? It sets an unbelievably shady precedent for publishers milking consumers that is unarguably even worse than “Day 1 DLC,” because the publisher is then, quite literally and knowingly, releasing an incomplete product with the intention of nickel and diming players who want to see the REST of the story.[/quote] Did I anywhere suggest that this… Read more »
Lambonius
Guest
[quote=Li-Ion][quote=Lambonius]What ISN’T a matter of opinion are the fact that it is riddled with glaring plot holes which *seem* to contradict everything that has been established earlier in the series. How is this not an issue for critics? I just don’t get it.[/quote] It´s only riddled with plotholes if you believe everything you see. Please have a look at any of these 2 videos (needless to say: massive SPOILERS): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ythY_GkEBck http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZZOyeFvnhiI%5B/quote%5D Yeah, I’ve seen those. The problem is that the Indoctrination Theory itself has some plotholes–not to mention the fact that as a storytelling device, Shepherd being Indoctrinated only works… Read more »
Lambonius
Guest

This is by far the best analysis of the failures of the Mass Effect 3 ending from a story-telling standpoint.

http://jmstevenson.wordpress.com/2012/03/22/all-that-matters-is-the-ending-part-2-mass-effect-3/

It clearly and objectively outlines all of the numerous, serious failures of the ending on several levels. As the analysis shows, this is not a matter of opinion. These are quantifiable, empirically observable failures. How can any critic who claims to value storytelling and narrative not find the endings objectionable?

If you look at all the articles about Skyrim’s narrative failures on this website, it really seems like there is a strange inconsistency going on here.

Matt
Guest
I found myself fixating on priority missions since Earth was in dire straights, which Admiral Hackett reminded me during every holocom chat. By the time I’d uncovered the extend of Cerberus’ evil machinations, I’d accumulated a bunch of Cerberus-related sidequests and character reintroduction scenarios. Powering through those at the end to pad my readiness rating seemed more like busywork than essential steps toward saving the galaxy. For every second I’m behind cover on a fetchquest on some random planet, a handful of humans back home are getting fried by a Reaper’s eyebeam, right? I also think Javik should have been… Read more »
Matt
Guest
I found myself fixating on priority missions since Earth was in dire straights, which Admiral Hackett reminded me during every holocom chat. By the time I’d uncovered the extend of Cerberus’ evil machinations, I’d accumulated a bunch of Cerberus-related sidequests and character reintroduction scenarios. Powering through those at the end to pad my readiness rating seemed more like busywork than urgent measures to save the organic life in the galaxy. For every second I’m behind cover on a fetchquest on some random planet, a handful of humans back home are getting fried by a Reaper’s eyebeam, right? Priorities, Shepard. I… Read more »
Li-Ion
Guest

[quote=Lambonius]What ISN’T a matter of opinion are the fact that it is riddled with glaring plot holes which *seem* to contradict everything that has been established earlier in the series. How is this not an issue for critics? I just don’t get it.[/quote]
It´s only riddled with plotholes if you believe everything you see.

Please have a look at any of these 2 videos (needless to say: massive SPOILERS):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ythY_GkEBck
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZZOyeFvnhiI

Lambonius
Guest
[quote=Flo] Here’s what puzzles me, though: Next to no reviewer (or critic, if you will) considers the ending to this story a major detraction, even if they admit to not liking it – which, as we have learned, stands in stark contrast to a big portion of the fanbase. Why is that? I can only imagine this disparity to stem from the critics’ often lesser immersion into the fiction. However, I have to argue that the beginning and ending to any story are the things one remembers most vividly, to the point where a dissapointing ending can indeed be detrimental… Read more »
Daniel
Guest
I’m having a hard time getting myself to play these. I got the first one on Steam as it was only $5, and quite enjoyed it. I even have a copy of Mass Effect 2, but after seeing what kind of online activation and registration and DLC and whatnot it entailed, I lost interest. The disc has never even been out of its box. From what I hear ME3 is even worse with all that Origin dung and no offline single-player. And a micro-transaction, free-2-play-style multiplayer mode? Really? As I see it, a publisher who tries to sell me a… Read more »
Li-Ion
Guest

I think this review is spot on. I enjoyed ME3 all the way through and also found the ending quite good. Not perfect, not mindblowingly awesome or anything like that, but for sure not as atrocious as the angry masses claim.

I’m thinking of starting a ME1-2-3 playthrough. Will take a while.

Flo
Guest
Troll comment: Glad to hear you enjoyed the ending, which colour did you get? Serious comment: I think the word “epilogue” is completely unsuitable to describe the entire third installment of a trilogy. Usually, an epilogue is a bit of story which comes after the final descending action or may in some cases be a part of that, and doesn’t account for a third of a story’s running time. ME3 being the epilogue would also imply that ME2 would be the “climax”, which I’m sure you’d find hard to agree with. Maybe I’m nit-picky, but you’re not the first to… Read more »
John
Guest
[quote=adembroski]The issue with the ending is that it totally invalidates the rest of the game. The combat is great, I loved it. Most of the action sequences absolutely satisfied me. The story is solid, up until the last ten minutes. My two complaints- and it seriously is only two complaints- First is that they’ve taken a LOT of Dialogue out of the player’s hands, and it really annoys me to watch Shepard talk on his own for ten minutes at a time. Second- that horrendously non-nonsensical ending that invalidates everything you did. It really makes me feel like the entire… Read more »
adembroski
Guest
The issue with the ending is that it totally invalidates the rest of the game. The combat is great, I loved it. Most of the action sequences absolutely satisfied me. The story is solid, up until the last ten minutes. My two complaints- and it seriously is only two complaints- First is that they’ve taken a LOT of Dialogue out of the player’s hands, and it really annoys me to watch Shepard talk on his own for ten minutes at a time. Second- that horrendously non-nonsensical ending that invalidates everything you did. It really makes me feel like the entire… Read more »
Justin
Guest

This has been up for an entire 2 hours and there aren’t already 200 posts decrying the score?

Crofto
Guest
Never understood how anyone gleaned much beyond a generic, clichéd space opera from these games. Indeed, were Mass Effect released in TV/film form I doubt many would find it of value besides a small cult of people whom would likely enjoy it for its unintended hilarity, rather than superb story-telling. I honestly don’t think BioWare have, or ever will, surpass the writing and narrative delivered in KotOR, but perhaps that’s just me. In any case, I’m somewhat surprised that you’re so enthusiastic for ME3 Brad, but understand where you’re coming from (besides praise for the narrative/writing). Personally, I don’t think… Read more »
Tim Spaeth
Guest

/unretire

Nailed it.

/re-retire

wpDiscuz