Game Description: In this highly anticipated sequel to Metroid Prime, become the bounty hunter behind the visor once more and travel to a planet torn into light and darkness. Hunted by a mysterious entity and a warring race called the Ing, Samus Aran must explore the light and dark worlds of this doomed planet to discover secrets and augment her suit's weapons and abilities.
Metroid Prime was the Nintendo success story of this generation, resurrecting the series (which has famously underperformed in the East but thrived in the West) at just the right time and in just the right way. Sandwiched between the hesitant critical praise that greeted both Super Mario Sunshine and The Wind Waker, Prime offered the most convincing reason not to write-off Nintendo as a major player in the industry, and served as stone cold proof that it had more to offer a contemporary—and crucially, Western—audience than the same old elfin quests and cartoonish jumping games. This sequel, pre-empting a new wave of similarly high-profile, mature exclusives like Resident Evil 4, Killer 7 and the newly re-imagined Legend of Zelda game, has perhaps less of a point to make, but it has a still significant legacy to uphold and consolidate, and that's exactly what Retro Studios have done.
That little has changed in two years is a testament to how excellent the core ingredients of Prime were in the first place. The map is still flawless, as is the first-person platforming, as are the camera transitions, etc. Disappointingly, the newest feature is a rather old one: namely that there is a light world and a parallel dark world (or "Aethers," for the pedantic) between which the player must travel in order to fully explore the dimensionally split planet that is the game's setting.
The interplay between the light and dark worlds may not be as incisively explored as in the best exemplars of the mechanic (Nintendo's own A Link To The Past or Ocarina Of Time for instance), but thanks to the unfailing technical brilliance of young Retro Studios in virtually every aspect of audio/visual game design there remains a palpable and worthwhile sense of contrast between the two. The inky Dark Aether is suitably hostile, with a poisonous atmosphere that saps Samus' energy when out of range of the (slowly) rejuvenating light crystals. Although the Light Aether is less impressive, feeling perhaps overly reminiscent of the first game's environments—Chozo Ruins and Tallon Overworld are strongly "referenced." Nevertheless, the mechanic comes across as more than just a way of artificially increasing the title's explorative depth by complicating the exploration process; it is integral to the whole feel and atmosphere of the game, communicating the world's otherworldliness better (and faster) than even Metroid Prime—if perhaps at the expense of some of Tallon IV's more organic feel.
Technically it's a marvel, the magnificent graphics almost too rich and sumptuous to take in all at once. Lavishly decorated rooms, assiduously detailed fauna, blinding (sometimes literally) spot-effects. (Yes, you still get to see Samus' reflection in the HUD visor.) And though the tunes may lack some of the bite and thematic distinctiveness of those in Prime (like the unforgettable bolero stomp of Magmoor Caverns), audio design is generally flawless and never intrusive unless it needs to be.
Speaking of intrusive, scanning has been made a little more bearable this time around. Not only is the visor color-coded to make scannable objects more easily identifiable, but there at last appears to be some much-needed dry humour injected into the many descriptions and log entries—Metroid's with food poisoning and misbehaving Space Pirates just add a little Nintendo character to the otherwise po-faced sci-fi landscape. There's no doubt that scanning can be laborious and detracts from more traditional "sight seeing" exploration, but it is entirely validated by its integrality to the experience and the eloquent ingenuity of a system that asks players to read up on the thing they're about to blast/activate. Hand in hand with the brave, economical and superbly calibrated control scheme, it helps ensure that Retro's Metroid still plays quite unlike any other game.
Similarly, combat maintains its typically "Nintendo" feel: strict rules, slightly mechanical, but inherently rhythmic; and all about concentration and timing. It lacks the unpredictability of more dynamic shooters (Halo being the prime—ahem—example) and you often won't fight unless you have to (some enemies seem created just to stall and annoy the player), but the consistency of the system mixed with the superb visual and audio effects combine to bring about fire fights which few can match for intensity and sheer fury.
Echoes pushes all the right panic buttons when it comes to confrontations, and the horrendous screams of some enemies as they reverberate behind the fleeing player are indicative of the rich stream of mature and affecting sci-fi horror that is maintained throughout. At the same time, it's still incredibly melancholic, perhaps even more uncompromising than its predecessor in favoring desolate, dying landscapes over more typically gamey settings (the ice and lava levels of Prime for instance). As ever, you're unlikely to play this Metroid game with a sparkling smile on your face. Mostly you'll maintain a fairly constant scowl—save for the satisfied grin that emerges after decimating one of the game's giant bosses—but that's no indictment of the game. Far from it, it's a rare game that forces the player to take it utterly seriously and become truly involved in the quest of their avatar. When trapped in a room full of Space Pirates, you really feel like you are fighting for your life. When scanning a new area for the first time, Samus' and the player's motivations are inextricably intertwined, and it's a bond that only tightens as you search to uncover a new pathway together.
As the game runs out of new environments towards the end, a certain laborious work ethic becomes apparent in the gameplay, and this problem (if it is a problem) is only compounded by the need to continually dimension-hop, deal with those aggravating respawning enemies, and a slightly cynical collection task near the game's conclusion that seriously ruptures the game flow just as it is reaching a climax.
However, the player's acquisition of new abilities is excellently planned out for the most part, and the addictive elegance of exploration is further tweaked and enhanced by the compulsion to use them in scouting out previously inaccessible areas. It's often hard to reason with a game that asks you to put in so much legwork, but Metroid Prime commands a power that few others can wield so effectively on their audience, and the pay-off dawns on the player when, by the end of the game, Samus has become possibly the most dazzlingly agile and empowered character yet seen in a first-person game.
Perhaps fittingly, this review has sounded an awful lot like a review of Metroid Prime, and that's because Echoes is an awful lot like Metroid Prime. Scratch that. It is Metroid Prime, but free from the pressures and expectations of being hailed as a landmark title and benefiting from a more clearly marked structure for progression, it is in some ways an even more enjoyable experience.
True, nearly everything in Echoes was also in its predecessor, but the merit in maintaining that game's superb balance whilst still making careful additions (Echoes bears the burden of flawlessly updating the screw attack into 3D with great élan), giving nearly every interface a new lick of paint (dig the sleek new menu design) and imbuing the game with its own uniquely foreboding atmosphere (with a moody synth score that's equal parts John Williams, Kraftwerk and Joy Division) cannot be understated. The echoes are resonating loud and clear all right, but their haunting majesty remains.
According to ESRB, this game contains: Animated Blood, Violence
As one of Nintendo's most mature franchises, Metroid Prime 2: Echoes pulls few punches when it comes to conveying the unsettling isolation of Samus Aran's world and the viciousness of its alien inhabitants. So while the game is devoid of realistic violence, Parents should be aware that it could be frightening for younger gamers.
Despite the new multiplayer mode being little more than a throwaway addition, Metroid Prime 2 still represents a fulsome and well-rounded package for its single-player campaign alone. The challenge is excellently pitched (which is not to be sniffed at in these days of massively varying audience abilities and attitudes) and fans of the series are well provisioned for with plenty of super-hidden items, and more concept art to unlock (via persistent scanning) than in its predecessor—although it seems generally weaker and less insightful than the design sketches gifted to Prime's more dedicated players.
Deaf and Hard of Hearing gamers may find the lack of lack of subtitles reprehensible for such an expensive, high-profile title, but they're really not needed: Echoes expounds classic videogame storytelling with the narrative artfully hinted towards through log entries, iconic symbols and unique sights rather than a reliance on cheap cinematic shortcuts or spoken dialogue. It is worth pointing out, however, that audio cues are often very useful when trying to track elusive enemies or master their attack patterns, and a not insignificant dimension of the experience is lost without the excellent mood-setting music and those piercing enemy screams.
Andrew is entirely correct in saying that the first Metroid Prime was Nintendo's success story for the current generation. It defied all odds by being a truly great experience in the face of so many obstacles stacked against it, stuffing crow in the mouth of everyone (including myself) who thought that bringing Samus Aran to living, breathing 3D was an impossible task. On the subject of Echoes, however, Andrew and I couldn't have more diverging opinions. Where he has appreciation and tolerance, I have nothing but impatience and scorn. Simply put, Metroid Prime 2: Echoes was far and away the most tedious and inspiration-free game that I actually bothered to finish in 2005.
Instead of seeing Echoes as upholding and consolidating a legacy, I see it as a blatant cash-in on Prime's success. Its only reason for existence was to fill Nintendo's coffers with my money while offering an experience that was indistinguishably identical at best, and painfully unpleasant at worst.
Technically, Echoes is as polished and proud as Andrew claims. There aren't any rough edges or glitches rearing their ugly heads anywhere in the game's vast world. The graphics are nice, and the controls still work. The disc's biggest crime is not related to the quality of its production values, but instead that it does absolutely nothing that wasn't already accomplished the first time around. What reason is there to sit through hours of the exact same item-finding, object-scanning and constant backtracking when Prime did it all, and did it perfectly?
Conceptually, the logic behind the game's plot and world are junk, hardly making any sense due to illogical inconsistencies and contrivances. The formula in Echoes is exactly the same as it was before: find items, open up new areas of the map, find more items, and repeat until the end. Many will argue that this play progression is vital and key to the identity of Metroid, but I say that it's high time the series gets a shakeup. The biggest hurdle—establishing a three-dimensional translation of something that was so essentially 2D—has been cleared. For that, I still give much respect to Retro Studios. On the other hand, the fact remains that every Metroid game has basically been a repeat of the original NES classic with bigger this or better that, and in my opinion, a series so rich with potential has to move on and start covering new ground. As a person who has played every single Metroid game, I'm beyond ready to see Samus Aran start tackling new challenges, exploring new play structures, and starting off an adventure without losing all of her equipment which somehow gets magically scattered throughout the alien world I've yet to explore.
If I had never played Prime and didn't have any history with the series, I suppose my estimation of the game would be higher, but my patience would still have been sorely tried. The worn-out concept of a light/dark dichotomy only makes getting through the game's too-large map convoluted and troublesome, adding a layer of irritation on top of the process. The new limits on ammunition serve no purpose except to aggravate, and the game's eleventh-hour fetchquest after receiving the last suit upgrade was the most disgustingly blatant waste of time I've seen in years. Not only was this fetching (again) an exact repeat of something established in Prime, it was an insulting slap in the face, nearly making me quit the game once I realized exactly what it was I was supposed to do.
I love the Metroid series and Samus Aran will always be a character I want to see more of, but unlike Andrew I simply can't accept such a creatively bankrupt effort. Metroid Prime 2: Echoes takes "playing it safe" to an unhealthy level and turns in a performance that reaches for nothing and accomplishes even less.